Innovations in Security Bollards: Hydraulic vs. Retractable vs. Fixed

Blog

Overview

Advancements in bollard design deliver tailored security solutions for diverse applications. Selecting the right bollard type balances deployment speed, reliability, and budget.

Fixed Bollards

  • Overview: Solid steel or concrete-filled posts are permanently anchored.
  • Pros: Lowest cost, minimal maintenance, immediate readiness.
  • Cons: No access flexibility.
  • Use Cases: Pedestrian zones, storefront protection.

Hydraulic Bollards

  • Overview: Powered by underground hydraulic pumps to raise/lower.
  • Pros: Fast deployment (<3 s), high impact ratings (50–100 kJ).
  • Cons: Higher installation cost, requires hydraulic maintenance.
  • Use Cases: Government checkpoints, diplomatic missions.

Retractable Bollards

  • Overview: Manually or electronically lowered into the ground for temporary access.
  • Pros: Flexible access control, moderate installation cost.
  • Cons: Lower impact rating than fixed or hydraulic.
  • Use Cases: Emergency vehicle access, event management.

Lifecycle Cost Comparison

Bollard Type Installation Cost Maintenance Frequency Typical Lifespan
Fixed Low Annual 25+ years
Hydraulic High Quarterly 15–20 years
Retractable Medium Biannual 10–15 years

 

Industry Use Cases

  • Government: Hydraulic for embassies.
  • Hospitality & Retail: Fixed for storefront protection.
  • Events & Emergency Services: Retractable for flexible access.

 

 

×